Newsletter - Links - Advertise - Contact Us - Privacy
 

A-listed Galashiels stadium makes its last stand

Bookmark and Share | Send to friend

May 20 2020

A-listed Galashiels stadium makes its last stand
David Narro Associates have been commissioned by Gala Fairydean Rovers to undertake repair and conservation of the A-listed Netherdale Stand in Galashiels.
 
A Brutalist masterpiece, renowned for offering football fans unobstructed views by banishing support pillars the future of the cantilevered canopy has been in doubt over recent years pending essential restoration work to water damaged concrete.
 
Commenting on their commission the structural engineering firm wrote: "An outstanding example of 1960’s Modernism, the improbable cantilevers of the stand’s canopy yields a structure of such remarkable elemental form it has gained a reverential status amongst architects and designers worldwide. The building is testament to both the singular ambition of its visionary architect, Peter Womersley, and of course the initiative and confidence of the custodians of the club at that time for undertaking such a commission.
 
"The building is made almost entirely of reinforced concrete and is virtually pure structure. The sculptural form, down to the deliberate board-marking of its cast surfaces, are key to its status as a brutalist masterpiece. That the building is such a work of art defines the key challenge of this project, which lies in the careful and conservative management of the natural ageing process of concrete as a structural material."
 
This reliance on reinforced concrete presents particular challenges for the design team, which includes Reiach & Hall, Morham & Brotchie and Irons Foulner, as they grapple with a material whose long-term behaviour remains an unknown quantity.
 
The practice added: "The conservative care and repair of architecturally important reinforced-concrete buildings and structures is a field of conservation in its infancy, in part because of a hitherto unfamiliarity with the long-term behaviour of the material and the technical capabilities of repair, but also because reinforced concrete is a wholly different thing from almost any other large-scale construction material: do the commonly-held, long-established philosophical approaches to the care and conservation of a traditional building apply?
 
"Our work, which is being led by a conservation accredited engineer, seeks to marry an approach of pragmatism and minimal intervention, with the use of compatible repair materials where intervention proves necessary, together with sensitive adoption of mitigation measures to stave off decay – all informed of course by a detailed understanding of the existing structure and its ageing and decay mechanisms."
 
Seating areas at the stand have been closed since 2018 while exploratory drilling has been carried out to ascertain the extent of damage to the concrete, which has begun to break away in parts.
Reinforced concrete has proven to be no match for the Borders climate
Reinforced concrete has proven to be no match for the Borders climate
The distinctive cantilevered canopy appears to defy the laws of physics
The distinctive cantilevered canopy appears to defy the laws of physics

The stand has fallen silent in recent years amid fears over spectator safety
The stand has fallen silent in recent years amid fears over spectator safety

8 Comments

Steve Palemerk
#1 Posted by Steve Palemerk on 20 May 2020 at 15:51 PM
It is well worth repairing and conserving - there are few twentieth-century buildings locally that deserve attention and the renovation of the Bernat Klein Studio seems to be permanently stalled: https://www.buildingsatrisk.org.uk/search/keyword/sELKIRK/event_id/902875/building_name/bernat-klein-studio-high-sunderland
Cadmonkey
#2 Posted by Cadmonkey on 20 May 2020 at 16:54 PM
Record it, and flatten it.
Glasgow Bob
#3 Posted by Glasgow Bob on 20 May 2020 at 19:26 PM
I'm with #2 on this one. Ugly Ugly Ugly.
Iain Duerr
#4 Posted by Iain Duerr on 21 May 2020 at 07:33 AM
That's a little unfair #2 and #3! Surely an identikit metal shed isn't preferable? I don't think the detritus that has built up on and around the structure over the years helps its image - signage tacked on, fence with peeling paint, bin!
FHM
#5 Posted by FHM on 21 May 2020 at 09:02 AM
You can tell that #2 and #3 are big fans of Prince Charles and probably think that Quinlan Terry is about as contemporary as they come.
SAndals
#6 Posted by SAndals on 21 May 2020 at 09:25 AM
Delighted to see this project getting underway. A good team involved and I'm sure once they resolve all the issues and restore the building's setting (and bar!) to original glory, then add some relevant additions, it will be great again!
Nairn's Bairn
#7 Posted by Nairn's Bairn on 21 May 2020 at 09:45 AM
Even before the whole deteriorating structure thing, I don't think I'd feel comfortable sitting under that.

Was it designed as such to make away fans uneasy?
The Bairn
#8 Posted by The Bairn on 21 May 2020 at 16:53 PM
It would be preferable to keep this unique structure as representative of a bygone age.
Surely with todays expertise and technology we can provide an excellent end result.

Post your comments

 

All comments are pre-moderated and
must obey our house rules.

 

Back to May 2020

Search News
Subscribe to Urban Realm Magazine
Features & Reports
For more information from the industry visit our Features & Reports section.