Newsletter - Links - Advertise - Contact Us - Privacy

Carbuncle clash spills onto the airwaves

October 10 2012

Carbuncle clash spills onto the airwaves
The Carbuncle Awards spilled over onto the airwaves for a spell this afternoon when a heated debate kicked off over the future of Scotland’s towns, following publication of the first nominees in this year’s Carbuncle Awards. They range from Culbokie on the Black Isle, described by Fraser MacKenzie as “a slightly motley collection of generic random housing styles", to Helensburgh, described as “tired and tatty” by Fraser Nelson.

Addressing the wider aims of the award however Urban Realm editor John Glenday outlined the merits of a nomination whilst speaking to John Beattie on BBC Radio Scotland: “It’s tongue in cheek but it does have a serious edge to it, these are important issues which need addressing. We’ve just heard from your contributors about issues ranging from the seemingly trivial, such as peeling paint, through boarded up shops to wider issues such as planning reform and how we tackle our smaller towns in the current economic climate. Our High Streets are in bad shape, businesses are closing down and we need to find new investment and new ways of bringing up our smaller communities.

“I think that’s where the Carbuncles can come in, particularly with Urban Realms expertise in the built environment, through architecture and planners, and actually what makes our smaller spaces tick and through our team of experts to assess what’s going wrong in some of these places and more importantly identifying what can be done to turn them around.”

Kevin Sayer, area services manager with Glenrothes Council, followed saying: “I’m not sure I buy all of that although I think anything that shines a light on progress in town centres isn’t necessarily a bad thing. I think disappointed is how we feel locally in Glenrothes, people will know that we won the beautiful Scotland Award earlier this year so we must be doing something right...”

Later Sayer added that winning the award "certainly prompted us to do more", despite it being "negative".

RIAS secretary Neil Baxter adopted a combative tack however, decrying the awards as a “crass PR stunt”, before adding that “awards should be about celebrating achievement and positive things and encouraging people to do better. They’re not about people parachuting in from grand offices, slagging somebody off and then leaving.”

Pointing out that the Carbuncles process does actually entail site visits to the towns with a professional team – often with community buy-in, Glenday cited the example of Denny which actively sought to secure the award. But Baxter, who publishes the rival RIAS Quarterly, interjected: “I don’t follow Urban Realm magazine, Urban Realm follows everyone else. So as far as Urban Realm is concerned, it’s useful for the litter bin and nothing else.”

This prompted Glenday to retort: “I think many would suggest that the RIAS is failing to raise awareness of many of these issues and debate them in public - so it’s left to other organisations to do your job.”

You can catch the full debate courtesy of BBC Radio Scotland from the 20min mark.


I L Design
#1 Posted by I L Design on 12 Oct 2012 at 12:55 PM
When don't architects include specific examples of recent individually designed projects which shame your profession ( of which there are many fine examples) rather than ridiculing poorly planned towns which have no specific responsible person to criticise ?
#2 Posted by Disgruntled on 12 Oct 2012 at 14:06 PM
I L Design agree wholeheartedly. When a building is well-designed the architects are well-praised. When a building or collection of buildings are badly designed and heaviliy criticised by the public, its the planners fault for approving apparently! Architects should stand up and be counted for the faults they make. The do after all design the individual buildings that make up our towns and cities!
#3 Posted by Stacey on 12 Oct 2012 at 15:14 PM
I L Design
Because there is no critical debate on architecture in Scotland?

Post your comments


All comments are pre-moderated and
must obey our house rules.


Back to October 2012

Search News
Subscribe to Urban Realm Magazine
Features & Reports
For more information from the industry visit our Features & Reports section.