Carbuncles refresh puts Scotland in the spotlight
August 24 2011
The annual awards, which aim to name and shame those places which are not living up to their full potential, were established in 2001 as a mechanism for furthering debate on the current condition of our secondary places and their future evolution.
Amongst the early front runners identified by Carbuncles judges are Fort William, the Highland town which serves instead as a low point for many having strangled by an elongated mass of tarmac and concrete along its waterfront.
In the ‘Pock Mark’ category for worst planning decision a number of contenders are already staking a claim to victory, amongst them the Timmer Market Clinic, Aberdeen, nominated by David Stewart who said: “The strange anodised crap-brown of the partial cladding allied to unfinished effect of the brickwork gives it that certain je ne c'est quoi.
“On top of that, a busy car park (in the part of town with the worst parking facilities) was used as the ground for this, and all the flats above the drug rehab clinic (100 yards from a school) have no parking.”
Carbuncles spokesperson John Glenday said: “In the ten years since the foundation of the Carbuncle awards we have witnessed great changes to both our built and economic landscapes.
“Unfortunately some things never change however and many of our communities still suffer from surroundings at least as bad as those we encountered in 2001.”
To be in with a chance of an Urban Realm sponsored makeover this year simply submit your nominations via www.urbanrealm.com/carbuncles or contact Urban Realm’s Carbuncles editor directly at firstname.lastname@example.org, or 0141 559 6087.
The deadline for nominations is September 15, with the award winners to be announced in the December edition of Urban Realm magazine.
Carbuncles were nominated with assistance from Urban Realm's editorial panel, including: Peter Wilson, Napier University; Alan Dunlop, architect; Alistair Scott; Smith Scott Mullan; Willie Miller, WMuD and Paul Stallan, RMJM
Read previous: Student flats plan for Edinburgh Church
Back to August 2011
Like us on Facebook
Become a fan and share
Features & Reports
For more information from the industry visit our Features & Reports section.